• About
    • History of Dallas SEO
  • Contact
  • Topics
    • Domain Security and Recovery
    • GoDaddy
    • ICANN and New gTLDs
    • AI Search
    • Google Search Updates
    • Google Ads and PPC
    • Google Business Profile and Local Search
    • Online Reputation Management
    • Bing
    • Blogging
    • Branding
    • Domain Names
    • Google
    • Internet Marketing
    • Link Building
    • Local Search
    • Marketing
    • Public Relations
    • Reputation Management
    • Search Engine Marketing
    • Search Engine Optimization
    • Search Engines
    • Social Media
  • Tech
  • Advertise
  • Services
    • Search Engine Optimization
    • Ongoing SEO Services
    • SEO Expert Witness
    • Google Penalty Recovery
    • Mini SEO Audit
    • Link Audit
    • Keyword Research
    • Combine Websites SEO Services
    • PPC Management
    • Online Reputation Management
    • Domain Name Consultant
    • Domain Names & Expired Domains
    • Domain Name Appraisal

Bill Hartzer

19 YearsSince 2007

Home » Search Engines » I Rebuilt Bruce Clay’s Search Engine Chart. Bing Feeds 11 Engines.

I Rebuilt Bruce Clay’s Search Engine Chart. Bing Feeds 11 Engines.

Posted on November 22, 2026 Written by Bill Hartzer

SearchEngines.net relationship chart showing Google, Microsoft Bing, Staan and Yandex supplying web results to fifteen other search engines, November 2026 edition.

Thirty-seven search engines are still open for business, and only four companies supply web results to any of the others. Microsoft Bing feeds eleven of those engines by itself. Those are the numbers on the relationship charts I published at SearchEngines.net on November 20, and they are the reason I drew the charts in the first place.

The idea is not mine. Bruce Clay published the first Search Engine Relationship Chart in 2000, more than two decades ago, and his company says it was downloaded 300,000 times in its first month. My version is an update with my own twist, published on a site I own. Read it as one consultant’s sourced map, not as a neutral audit.

Print the chart and find the engines your customers use. I have reviewed plenty of sites where nobody had ever opened Bing Webmaster Tools, and Bing is the index sitting behind Yahoo, DuckDuckGo, AOL Search and eight more.

Jump To

Toggle
  • Where The Idea Came From
  • What I Changed
  • What The 2026 Chart Shows
  • Why AI Search Needed A Separate Chart
  • What To Do With It
    • Related Posts

Where The Idea Came From

Bruce’s chart answered a question every search marketer had in 2000: who gets their results from whom? There were dozens of engines, and most of them borrowed listings from somebody else. His company kept the chart current for years. The historical view on its site runs from 2001 to 2017, and it describes the original this way:

the chart that everyone in the internet marketing industry had on their wall

That matches my memory.

Bruce died this year. I took his SEO (Search Engine Optimization) training years ago and worked for him on several projects, and I wrote about what he meant to me and to this industry in June. Updating his best-known idea felt like the right way to keep using what he taught.

What I Changed

I kept the concept and rebuilt everything else. Bruce’s chart covered engines, ad networks and directories. Mine tracks one thing: where the web results come from.

  • Every line restates a sourced fact: the engine’s own documentation, a contract disclosure, a court record or a regulator’s finding.
  • Every solid line marks a feed the engine names itself, and every dashed line marks one that is partial, purchased or disputed.
  • Every engine that will not name its supplier gets no line at all.
  • Every engine that has closed is gone, including Ask.com, which shut down on May 1, 2026.

That third rule matters most to me. As an expert witness, I do not get to guess, and a chart that guesses is decoration.

What The 2026 Chart Shows

Four index owners supply everyone else: Google, Microsoft Bing, Yandex and Staan, the European index run jointly by Ecosia and Qwant. Fifteen engines take results from one or more of them. Google supplies six, two of them on dashed lines. Bing supplies eleven.

Ten engines buy from no one and crawl the web themselves, Baidu, Naver, Brave Search and Mojeek among them. Eight more are metasearch engines or portals with mixed or undisclosed feeds.

In 2000 the problem was too many engines. In 2026 the problem is too few indexes.

SearchEngines.net is the same site where Google Search Console labels 77% of my clicks as branded, and the queries that bring people there ask for lists and directories of search engines. A list tells you who exists. The chart tells you who depends on whom.

Why AI Search Needed A Separate Chart

An AI search product has two suppliers, not one. A language model writes the answer, and a web index supplies the pages the answer draws on. Bruce’s format had no room for that, so I drew a second chart.

The AI chart covers 21 products worldwide, with six model makers on the left and three index suppliers on the right. ChatGPT search uses its own index and Bing’s. Yahoo Scout pairs an Anthropic model with Bing’s index. Claude searches through Brave. Apple Siri runs on a Google model and has not said whose index it uses, so that box has no line on the right.

Is this worth the effort for such a small slice of traffic? Semrush’s latest numbers show Google search is still more than seven times bigger than AI tools on U.S. desktops. I think the map matters anyway, because the AI products change suppliers far more often than the old engines ever did. That is why each chart carries an edition date.

What To Do With It

Start with the index owners, because they decide what the other engines can show.

  • Verify your site in Bing Webmaster Tools and confirm your key pages are indexed.
  • Check your robots.txt file and confirm it does not block Bingbot.
  • Download the PDF or PNG, which are free to print and share with the attribution and edition date left on.

The response on social media since I shared the charts has been good. A lot of us remember the original.

Thank you, Bruce.

Related Posts

  • Remembering Bruce Clay: The Father of SEO and a Friend Who Changed an Industry
  • Omnicom Media Group Acquires Bruce Clay Australasia
  • 2010 Charts a Promising Future for E-Commerce on Facebook
  • RyghtSites.com Launches: The Free AI Search Engine That Could Fix Clinical Trial Delays Overnight
  • The Mystery of “Bill Hartzer Disease”: A Deep Dive into Google Autosuggest Anomalies

Filed Under: Search Engines

About Bill Hartzer

Bill Hartzer is the CEO of Hartzer Consulting and founder of DNAccess, a domain name protection and recovery service. A recognized authority in digital marketing and domain name strategy, Bill is frequently called upon as an Expert Witness in internet-related legal cases. He's been sharing his insights, expertise, and research here on BillHartzer.com for over two decades.

Bill Hartzer on Search, Marketing, Tech, and Domains.

Hartzer Domains

DFWSEM logo

 

 

Brand Ambassador for:

Majestic logo

Oncrawl logo

Semrush logo

Industry Friends

  • David Daniels
  • WTFSEO
  • SEO By the Sea
  • Jeff Lenney
  • Jeff Gabriel
  • Scott Hendison
  • Dixon Jones
  • Brian Hartzer
  • Navah Hopkins
  • DNAccess
  • Hartzer on IT.com
  • Jason Olson

Connect With Bill Hartzer

  • Bill Hartzer on X
  • Bill Hartzer on BlueSky
  • Bill Hartzer on Instagram
  • Hartzer Consulting on Facebook
  • Bill Hartzer on Facebook
  • Bill Hartzer on YouTube

Recent Posts

  • I Rebuilt Bruce Clay’s Search Engine Chart. Bing Feeds 11 Engines.
  • XYZ Applied for the .SEO Domain. The Price Will Decide Who Uses It
  • Goodfirms Says Organic Traffic Grew for 66.3%. Nobody Checked.
  • adMarketplace Says AI Chat Ad Conversions Rose 156%. From What?
  • ICANN Opens Comments on 1,606 New gTLDs. A Comment Is Not an Objection
  • LinkedIn Leads at 5.8%, but Vista Social’s Own Data Says Don’t Compare
  • The FBI Just Put SEO in a Ransomware Alert. Site Owners Should Listen
  • My GA4 Showed 215,440 Sessions. About 680 Were Real People.
  • MyStation Says Creators Can Own a TV Network. Read the Fine Print.
  • Constant Contact’s Catalyst AI Will Run Your Marketing. Who Checks It?

Bill Hartzer

News and analysis on search, marketing, tech and domain names since 2001.

Hartzer Consulting

Topics

  • Google Search Updates
  • AI Search
  • Google Ads and PPC
  • Google Business Profile and Local Search
  • Domain Security and Recovery
  • ICANN and New gTLDs
  • GoDaddy
  • Online Reputation Management

Site

  • About Bill Hartzer
  • Contact
  • Services
  • Advertise
  • All Topics

Legal

  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Entity Map

Copyright 2026 by Bill Hartzer and Hartzer Consulting, LLC.

Website, Content, and Marketing by Hartzer Consulting, LLC.