A report from Blue Hour Studios reveals that traditional approaches to influencer marketing are losing their edge. The study, titled The New Rules of Influence, sheds light on how brands can revamp their strategies to thrive in today’s social media landscape.
Influencer marketing is undergoing a profound transformation, forcing brands to adapt or risk falling behind. According to Blue Hour Studios’ report, The New Rules of Influence, the traditional reliance on demographics and follower counts is outdated. Instead, marketers must prioritize shared interests, engaging content, and audience resonance. This shift is driven by the evolving behaviors of social media users and platform algorithm changes, as highlighted by a study of 1,000 American social media users.
Interests Over Demographics
The study revealed that aligning with audience interests is nearly twice as impactful as demographic targeting in driving sales. A staggering 78% of respondents said they are more likely to buy from brands that align with their passions, while 85% indicated their interests often transcend generational boundaries.
Monika Ratner, Head of Growth at Blue Hour Studios, emphasized the shift: “Success today isn’t about fitting consumers into narrow demographic boxes. It’s about understanding what truly excites them and finding creators who share those passions.” Brands must focus on identifying influencers who authentically connect with niche interests such as fitness, travel, or gaming to create genuine resonance and trust.
Viewership Beats Follower Counts
The outdated obsession with follower numbers is being replaced by metrics that measure engagement and reach. The research found that influencers at any level—whether celebrity, macro, mid-tier, or micro—can drive similar purchase behavior if their content consistently attracts views and engagement.
This aligns with platform changes, as Instagram’s head Adam Mosseri recently noted: “Sends per reach and views are the most important metrics across all content types.” With the majority of views now coming from non-followers, an influencer’s ability to appeal to a broader audience is critical. Brands must evaluate how content performs beyond the follower base, emphasizing quality over quantity.
Algorithm Engagement Is Key
Social media users are more intentional than ever in curating their feeds. Over half of the study’s respondents reported actively “training” algorithms to deliver content that aligns with their interests, with Gen X leading this trend. Influencers who balance education, entertainment, and escapism capture the most attention and loyalty across generations.
Tools to Navigate the Shift: Swell.AI
To help brands adapt to these changes, Blue Hour Studios introduced Swell.AI, a proprietary tool designed to refine influencer marketing strategies. Swell.AI focuses on three core areas:
- Swell Factor: A data-driven index evaluating influencers’ content and interests against brand goals, removing bias from talent selection.
- Swell Rating: A predictive system that assesses viewership potential on a simple 1-to-10 scale, moving past outdated micro-to-macro categorizations.
- Swell Brief: A tool aligning influencer content with audience preferences, ensuring campaigns resonate on platforms like TikTok’s For You Page.
Why This Matters for Marketers
The implications of this shift are significant. Marketers must abandon outdated follower-based tier systems and instead analyze influencers’ ability to engage audiences across the broader social media ecosystem. The focus should be on relevance and resonance, leveraging tools like Swell.AI to make data-driven decisions.
Key takeaways include:
- Interests Drive Sales: Shared passions are more effective than demographics in influencing purchasing decisions.
- Engagement Over Follower Size: Influencers of all tiers can deliver results when their content resonates with audiences.
- Active Curation by Users: Over half of social media users fine-tune their feeds, favoring content that educates, entertains, and provides escapism.
Methodology
Blue Hour Studios conducted the research in September 2024, surveying 1,000 active social media users across generations, including Gen Z, Millennials, and Gen X. Insights were validated using proprietary tools and social media audits, uncovering critical trends reshaping influencer marketing.
The Future of Influencer Marketing
Brands clinging to outdated strategies risk irrelevance in an ever-evolving digital landscape. As Monika Ratner succinctly states: “Finding creators who align with what your audience loves isn’t just good marketing—it’s the future.” By embracing this new era of influencer marketing, brands can foster meaningful connections with their audiences and achieve sustained success.